09. Inquiry into Building Quality

The Standing Committee on Economic Development and Tourism has completed its inquiry into Building Quality in the ACT.

The Committee released a discussion paper in April 2018 to provide those interested in making a submission with some background on the current regulatory regime and some of the key issues that they may wish to consider.

The Committee tabled its final report on 23 July 2020.

The Committee tabled a corrigenda on 27 August 2020 to reflect an editorial correction. The final report has been updated to include the correction.

Any further enquiries can also be directed to the Committee Secretary, on 620 50435 or email at: LACommitteeEDT@parliament.act.gov.au

The Standing Committee on Economic Development and Tourism resolves to inquire into and report on the quality of new buildings in the ACT and any potential or actual causes of poor building quality in the ACT with particular consideration given to:

1. The certification regime for the building and construction industry including;

  1. Review by certifiers of the initial building plans;
  2. Compliance by builders with the building’s approved construction plans;
  3. The adequacy of regulatory mechanisms to ensure compliance with approved construction plans;
  4. The role of inspections and audits in the regulatory process; and
  5. The appropriateness of current practices for appointing certifiers, including addressing the potential for conflicts of interest.

2. The merits of standard contracts or statutory requirements in contracts covering build quality.

3. Industry skills accreditation and ongoing professional development including;

  1. The breadth of the occupational licensing regime in the ACT; and
  2. The suitability of ongoing skills education and practices within the industry.

4. Processes and practices for the identification and rectification of defects including;

  1. Current mechanisms available for defect identification and redress;
  2. The effectiveness of those mechanisms to ensure rectification in instances where standards have not been met;
  3. The adequacy and accessibility of those mechanisms especially for individuals or body corporates; and
  4. The effectiveness of efforts to address “phoenixing” – the transfer of assets from an indebted building company to a new one to avoid paying its liabilities.

5. The cost effectiveness of current building compliance and defect rectification practices for industry, government, individuals or body corporates and the potential for the introduction of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms.

6. The role of Access Canberra.

7. The regulatory setting or practices in other jurisdictions that could inform consideration of any of the above.

8. Personal experiences that could inform consideration of any of the above.

9. Any other relevant matter.

For the purposes of clarity the Committee wishes to inform submitters that it is not inquiring into compliance with approved development applications.

DescriptionPDFWord
Discussion paper PDF (1.0 MB)
DescriptionPDFWord
103 Attachment C PDF (81.6 KB)
103 Attachment B PDF (527.5 KB)
103 Attachment A PDF (1.2 MB)
103 Petrovic PDF (487.7 KB)
102 Anonymous PDF (290.1 KB)
100 Downs PDF (235.2 KB)
099 Resosudarmo PDF (283.0 KB)
098 Anonymous PDF (311.0 KB)
097 Cummins PDF (229.6 KB)
096 Zeil PDF (481.6 KB)
095 Anonymous PDF (275.9 KB)
094 Withdrawn PDF (191.7 KB)
093 Confidential PDF (191.8 KB)
092 Confidential PDF (191.3 KB)
091 Confidential PDF (191.3 KB)
090 Anonymous PDF (301.9 KB)
089 Confidential PDF (223.8 KB)
088 AMCA PDF (723.8 KB)
087 Anonymous PDF (297.7 KB)
086 Wood PDF (325.0 KB)
085 McCormack PDF (487.2 KB)
084 Confidential PDF (191.7 KB)
083 Tranzillo PDF (341.3 KB)
082 Bektas PDF (337.9 KB)
081 Champness PDF (350.8 KB)
080 Moloney PDF (444.5 KB)
079 Canale PDF (322.8 KB)
078 Anonymous PDF (429.6 KB)
077b Australian Institute of Architects - annex 1 - Submission PDF (306.2 KB)
077a Australian Institute of Architects PDF (500.8 KB)
076b Domovina - annex 1 - photos PDF (852.7 KB)
076a Domovina PDF (257.3 KB)
075 Master Builders Association PDF (12.2 MB)
074 Raj PDF (308.5 KB)
073 Howard PDF (2.0 MB)
072 Keeley PDF (383.0 KB)
071 HIA PDF (1.3 MB)
070 Seaniger PDF (282.1 KB)
069 ACT Government PDF (1.3 MB)
068 Anonymous PDF (371.3 KB)
067 Bursill PDF (272.0 KB)
066 Haiduk PDF (268.8 KB)
065 Rosser and Skvorc PDF (228.4 KB)
064 Payne PDF (322.5 KB)
063 Kiely PDF (299.6 KB)
062 Smithurst. PDF (286.6 KB)
061 Anonymous PDF (347.9 KB)
060 Robinson PDF (256.2 KB)
059 Olley PDF (18.6 MB)
058 Jayasekara PDF (2.6 MB)
057 Hopner PDF (1.8 MB)
056 McKay PDF (232.5 KB)
055 Kingston and Barton Resident's Group PDF (1.4 MB)
054 Anonymous PDF (1.1 MB)
053 Inner South Canberra Community Council PDF (383.1 KB)
052 Olley PDF (325.0 KB)
051 Taylor PDF (330.2 KB)
050 Engineers Australia PDF (2.5 MB)
049 CFMEU PDF (803.1 KB)
048 Combined Community Councils PDF (824.0 KB)
047 Australian Institute of Building Surveyors PDF (8.6 MB)
046 Sherwin PDF (405.8 KB)
045 Pinkas PDF (409.3 KB)
044 Vista executive committee PDF (268.7 KB)
043 Grant PDF (916.6 KB)
042 Anonymous PDF (218.3 KB)
041a Australia Institute of building attachment PDF (1.2 MB)
041 Australia Institute of building PDF (619.7 KB)
040 Chen PDF (226.0 KB)
039 E Martin PDF (328.1 KB)
038 Anonymous PDF (919.0 KB)
037 Canberra Business Chamber PDF (735.2 KB)
036 Matkovic PDF (254.4 KB)
035 Davis and Rudkin PDF (257.5 KB)
034 Ghildyal PDF (284.5 KB)
033 Corcoran PDF (211.0 KB)
032 Yang PDF (287.3 KB)
031 ACT Manhattan PDF (260.3 KB)
030 Guo & Wu Family Pty Ltd PDF (285.6 KB)
029 Artur Baumhammer PDF (260.6 KB)
028 Name withheld PDF (264.1 KB)
027 Todd Garratt PDF (248.5 KB)
026 Scott and Aimee Hunter PDF (268.0 KB)
025 Samintha Pathiranage and Kumara Weligama PDF (257.4 KB)
024 Natalie Bice and Brendan Pratt PDF (252.7 KB)
023 Owners Corporation Network PDF (429.6 KB)
022 Daniel Christiadi PDF (242.9 KB)
021 Kylie Fitzsimmons PDF (246.1 KB)
020 Kerin Benson Lawyers PDF (543.5 KB)
019 David Berston PDF (238.0 KB)
018 Raymond David PDF (301.4 KB)
017 Lauren Upton PDF (286.3 KB)
016 Pascal Deschanel PDF (2.7 MB)
015 Taneill Jager PDF (189.6 KB)
014 Suzanne Maginnity PDF (828.0 KB)
013 Shannon Cuthbertson PDF (342.1 KB)
012 Steven and Melinda Kouparitsas PDF (322.3 KB)
011 Glenda Toffolon PDF (199.0 KB)
010 Executive Committee Units Plan 3089 PDF (188.6 KB)
009 Irene Pellegrino PDF (214.9 KB)
008 Anonymous PDF (220.4 KB)
007 Stephen & Amanda Peeks PDF (339.8 KB)
006 Anonymous PDF (260.5 KB)
005 Cheng Fei PDF (187.6 KB)
004 June Keogh PDF (189.2 KB)
003 Brad Kane PDF (206.9 KB)
002 Andrew Martin PDF (174.9 KB)
001 Hugh Dakin PDF (221.3 KB)

Go to current public hearings schedule

View committee hearings transcripts

Public Hearings:

10 April, 1, 8, 22, 29 May, 24 July, 7 & 28 August, 4 September 2019

DescriptionPDFWord
Report 9 - Inquiry into Building Quality PDF (854.6 KB) Word (2.9 MB)
DescriptionPDFWord
Government response tabled 2 December 2020 PDF (458.1 KB)
DescriptionPDFWord
Opening Statement - Kerin Benson Lawyers, 22 May 2019 PDF (241.8 KB)
Opening Statement - David Raymond, 1 May 2019 PDF (186.9 KB)
Opening Statement - David McKay, 8 May 2019 PDF (7.5 KB)
Opening Statement - Brad Kane, 8 May 2019 PDF (220.3 KB)
Media release - Further submissions on building quality in the ACT welcome PDF (102.2 KB)
Media release - Committee announces inquiry into building quality in the ACT PDF (108.9 KB)
Exhibit - Letter from Owners Corporation Network to Minister for Planning 30 June 2010 PDF (526.8 KB)
Exhibit - Letter from Mr Barr Minister of Planning re building defects 7 June 2010 PDF (204.6 KB)
Exhibit - Email from Alistair Swayn former ACT Architect 8 December 2014 PDF (134.0 KB)
Exhibit - Bring Back the Clerk of Works _ ACA - Association of Consulting Architects A PDF (223.5 KB)
Exhibit - Australian Institute of Architects summary of Shergold Weir report July 2018 PDF (372.2 KB)